Janis Brenner: The body does not forget

by | Mar 28, 2012 | Personal Stories | 0 comments

Janis Brenner

Professional dancers are different from the rest of us.  But there’s one significant way that they’re not different.

Read this article that my guest author, Janis Brenner, wrote a few years back for DanceView Magazine.  She outlines the many layers of injury and bodily stress that have punctuated her years as a dancer, choreographer, singer, and teacher.

Seems like a steep price to pay.

But her story isn’t much different than that of most of my patients, whether they’re dancers, architects, elementary school teachers, or anything else.

You may not think that you earn a living by moving your body.  But you do.

And, like Janis, your accumulated injuries, accidents, spills, aches and pains have a significant cumulative effect.

But the effect isn’t all negative.  Everything that has happened to you becomes part of your story. You can pretend to ignore the incidents of the past, but your body doesn’t forget.

danceview Magazine


by Janis Brenner

There is a body I would like to believe that I own, but the truth is it owns me and always

This body rules my sleep, my work, my play, my dreams. Every morning before a clear
thought can be formulated, it wakes me to its callings. My “forty-something”-year-old
dancer’s feet take their first hesitant, weighted steps and message me right up through the
ankles, up the Achilles, inside the calf muscle to the back of my knee and around the inside
to the patella.

Some days the little calls for help manage to stop there after I have taken a full stroll
around the living room. Then I begin to hear from my neck and shoulders, the left
side testing to see if I still remember l975’s rib crunch when the Freed twins, Morris and
Oliver, were figuring out how to lift all ninety-five pounds of me in a leap combination by
digging their fingers in under my left breast and underarm until I could no longer breathe.
Somehow the crunch traveled up my side, set up house in my shoulder socket, and has lived
there ever since.

There is the ritual twist-to-the-left crack of my lower spine that needs to happen before
breakfast which sometimes determines whether I gather the motivation to get myself to
dance class or just get back into bed. If the dull ache at the base of my skull goes beyond a
2.5 on the throb scale, I choose to give in to taking the two Tylenol or to calling Drs. Castro,
Calvano or Cai for the never-ending, expensive and only temporary Chiropractic healing.

Then there’s the slightly less mobile right thumb from l983; broken from smashing into
Danny Shapiro on stage while wearing an Alwin Nikolais-invented, black-mesh netting over
my face that my eyelashes were entangled in, preventing me from seeing where the hell I
was going. I still picture the costume designer of the show chiding me only the day before
the thumb smash for complaining to him about the face encasement, assuming I was just
being a primadonna who had long eyelashes. Perhaps breaking my thumb was my perverse,
masochistic way of saying “ I told you so”.

There’s the torn-ligament-of-my-left-foot reminder from l984, incurred while on an
outdoor stage in France with the Dave Brubeck Quartet in what was meant to be my final
performance after seven years with the Murray Louis Dance Company. In the opening
minute of “Glances”, a dance I had performed at least one hundred times before, I jumped
up to push Rob McWilliams’ chest and came down onto the outer rim of my sickling, left
foot. Not able to even remotely stand back up, I crawled off the stage between Rob’s upright
legs, his state-of-shock face watching me peddle off underneath him like a wounded

Janis Brenner

Janis Brenner

As I dragged myself into the wing, Dave Brubeck yelled out sympathetically, “Are you
going to be able to get up, Princess?” “I don’t think so, Dave”, I managed to blurt out before
realizing the agony I was in. That fall was a direct and swift punishment from the Dance
Gods. Having shown up late to the theater, I did not have time to warm up properly before
the show because I had been” busy” with someone I should not have been busy with at 5
o’clock in the afternoon…or at all.

And then there is the hidden, little crevice in my forehead–the “il dento piccolo”– from the
Italian bus crash of ‘78. Traveling to Florence, the final destination on my first and the
company’s longest European tour in its history, our tour bus skids off the highway into the
on-coming traffic. It topples over onto its side, is slid into by a Semi-truck and
miraculously, all twelve of us manage to hobble out through the shattered front window.
Three of us have cuts, including Murray, one has bruises from having all the luggage fall on
top of him, the rest are severely shaken and disoriented and I have a concussion.

Whenever I am still made aware of the little dent, occasionally on rainy days, I think
immediately of Shakespeare. I’m right back in the Florence hospital having electrodes wired
to my skull for an EKG. I am so petrified the doctors will discover brain damage that I’m
literally reciting, “To be or not to be…that is the question…” outloud, so they’ll notice I can
still make thoughts. Much later on, after everyone in the company has made it home, it
occurs to me that reciting Shakespeare soliloquies outloud in an Italian hospital ward no
doubt made me appear even crazier.

Right next to the dent is the bump and memories of my head, Halloween and helmets.
We’re dancing Murray Louis’ work “Proximities” in some theater in Queens, N.Y. on a rainy
Halloween night when Rob, whipping around at break-neck speed, accidentally does a front
battement kick straight to my forehead. I have no recollection of whether I fell, stood frozen
in time or somehow continued with the steps. But I do remember being helped back to the
dressing room where Murray has run in carrying a long, shiny object. “Here, doll”, he says,
“put this spoon on your head right away!”

I am nauseous, disoriented and drained of any energy even to ask why, so I sit there holding a
metal spoon against the bump, which is next to the dent, probably reciting Shakespeare.
Following this incident, the company chipped in and bought me a custom-made, navy-blue
football helmet with “BRENNER” emblazoned across the front in embossed, red letters. For a
while I wore it at the beginning of each rehearsal day, partly as a joke, but also as a warning
to all to pay attention and stay away from my head.

It was back in l974 that I left college after two years and moved to New York City to study
with Alwin Nikolais and Murray Louis. Three weeks into the fall term at their school, I
fractured the right foot’s metatarsal while jumping sideways across the studio floor with the
rest of the class.

For the next three months I came to the studio every day to observe and
take notes, but also to bemoan my sorry state and wonder if this less-than-auspicious
beginning of my life as an artist in New York was a sign of things to come. Once or twice a
year now, when I jump off the foot, the cracked metatarsal again yells up at me, for no
reason I can immediately understand. But what I have come to see, almost appreciate, is the
momentary flash of recognizing that 20-year-old girl again; in the throes of learning to
jump sideways, to plie better, to move more deeply from the inside–all the things I am still
working on twenty-three years later. This makes the momentary foot re-crack strangely

When I left the Murray Louis Dance Company in 1984, my helmet went with me. It took me
years to finally discard that possession because I knew it had come to represent all those
accidents and injuries as well as memories of times, people and places I wanted to hold

The associations had become emotional souvenirs or even trophies. All of those
incidents altered my daily life, and my dancing life, in some way–whether minutely or
momentously–and for that reason I had needed to think of them as keepsakes. My life had
become housed in my body.

Martha Graham once said, “Movement doesn’t lie.” To which I would add, “The body doesn’t


Deepen Your Body of Knowledge

More on Dancer Injuries

Another Reminder that Paying Attention to Your Body Matters

Universal Significance of Dance


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Ask Dr. Lavine about….

the cat-cow stretch can help with low back pain

Five star chiropractor


8 best self-care tips for the health of your spine

To claim your free guide, simply enter your email address below.

You'll also be joining Dr. Lavine's e-mail list for periodic updates filled with useful health information and self-care strategies.

We value your privacy and will never spam you. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Thank you! Please Check your inbox to validate your email

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This

Share this post with your friends!